About the song
Bruce Springsteen’s rendition of “Don’t Play That Song” isn’t your typical Boss anthem. Released in 2022 on his album Only the Strong Survive (a collection of soul covers), it marks a departure from his usual rock sound. But even with a soulful twist, the song still carries the emotional weight Springsteen is known for.
Originally a Soul Classic:
“Don’t Play That Song” (originally titled “Don’t Play That Song (You Lied)”) has a rich history in soul music. Written by Ahmet Ertegun and Betty Nelson, it was first recorded by Ben E. King in 1962 and became a major hit, reaching number two on the R&B charts. Aretha Franklin later covered it in 1970, achieving even greater success with a number one spot on the R&B charts.
Springsteen’s Take:
Springsteen’s version retains the core of the song – a plea to stop a song from playing because it brings back painful memories of a past love. The lyrics evoke a youthful romance that ended in heartbreak. The speaker remembers sweet beginnings (“our first date”), empty promises (“you told me you loved me”), and ultimately, betrayal (“darlin’, you lied”).
Themes of Nostalgia and Heartbreak:
The song explores the bittersweet nature of nostalgia. Hearing the familiar song triggers a flood of memories, both happy and sad. Springsteen’s powerful vocals convey the raw emotions of longing and regret. He doesn’t dwell on anger, but rather a sense of vulnerability and the enduring pain of a love lost.
A Departure and a Connection:
While “Don’t Play That Song” is a departure from Springsteen’s usual rock sound, it still connects with his signature themes. The song explores the struggles of love and loss, themes that resonate throughout his vast catalog. It also showcases his versatility as a vocalist, proving his ability to deliver a soulful performance alongside the powerful rock anthems for which he’s known.